26 Apr 2013



Lucy Trent is used to having the legend of her glamorous grandmother unearthed from time to time - the infamous silent-screen actress Lucretia von Wolff, whose life ended abruptly in a bizarre double murder and suicide at the Ashwood film studios in 1952. Lucy quite enjoys Lucretia's legend, although the rest of her family would prefer it to be quietly forgotten.

But when a body is found in the now-derelict studios, brutalised in a macabre echo of the 50-year-old case, disturbing facts about the past begin to emerge ..... Facts which point back to the eerie legend of the child known simply as Alraune. The child named after Lucretia's most famous film. The child who may never have existed at all.

In the ensuing murder investigations, Lucy is to discover the truth about her family's dark and often poignant history - a history which spans the glittering concert halls of 1920's Vienna to the bleak environs of wartime Auschwitz. And at the heart lies the shocking truth about the mysterious child called Alraune.
....... Outer back cover.

FIRST SENTENCE (Chapter 1): It is not every day that your family's ghosts come boiling out of the past to disrupt your ordinary working day.

MEMORABLE MOMENT (Page 430): He has never known the ordinary world, thought Alice, only this dark hopeless place. So he may see nothing horrific in what they are about to do, and he may be unaffected by it. And then, far down in her mind, she thought: but I don't want him to be unaffected! I want him to be capable of pity and compassion - to be able to put himself in another's place - to feel hurt when a friend hurts.

MY THOUGHTS: By no means the easiest of reads, Roots Of Evil is definitely a contender for the most confusing and possibly frustrating book I have ever read.

Flitting back and forth between present day England and 'cousins' Lucy and Edmund, 1920's Vienna and the 'birth' of the enigmatic Lucretia von Wolff, and the concentration camp of Auschwitz was difficult enough but even more confusing was that the whole novel reminded me of a jigsaw puzzle that slowly, piece by piece, is seemingly coming together to reveal the whole picture until you realise several pieces seem to be missing.

Intriguing rather then enjoyable, one of those books I feel I shouldn't have liked and yet did. Dark and yet sinister in a somewhat understated kind of way, at times, gruesomely graphic, it read like a Gothic horror novel. At others like the worst kind of 'slasher' novel though, oddly enough, with echoes of Shakespeare's King Lear.

Without a doubt a very different read and one well worth persevering with (thank goodness all of the pieces did eventually come together even if it was sometimes hundreds of pages later) despite all of the largely implausible twists and turns of the plot and fairly stereotypical characters.

KEEP IT OR NOT?: Not a book I'll be buying, My thanks to Leanne for the loan of it.

Protection: All original content on http://pettywitter.blogspot.co.uk/ is created by the website owner, including but not limited to text, design, code, images, photographs and videos are considered to be the Intellectual Property of the website owner, whether copyrighted or not, and are protected by DMCA Protection Services using the Digital Millennium Copyright Act Title 17 Chapter 512 (c)(3). Reproduction or re-publication of this content is prohibited without permission.
In addition I would also urge that if you are reading this on any other page you contact the original blog owner/reviewer.


Jean said...

This sounds like a book I'd have loved a few years ago and that I'd like to love now - but I don't have my wits about me - I have trouble just following ordinary plots these days. I wish I could say no to drugs!

Kelly said...

I'm glad it was worth the effort for you and it sounds like one I might enjoy. I always liked "Gothic" novels. Fun opening line, too!

Lindsay said...

Thanks for your honest review of this one. I don't think I would rush to read it but I was interested to know more abou tit.

Barbara said...

Well, the first sentence had me hooked, but I’m not so sure after reading the rest of the review. Sometimes the easiest way with this kind of book is to write yourself a ‘crib sheet’ something that you can refer to when all the twists and turns become too much. But can I be bothered – maybe one day, when I retire and have all the time in the world! Thanks for the excellent review.

EC Stilson said...

It does sound intriguing. But not my regular read.

I just saw your comment on Wayman's blog. I think the giveaway glitch is fixed now.
I had problems with it earlier too.
Here's that link: http://www.goodreads.com/giveaway/show/51205-so-much-time-so-little-change

Sorry to put this on your blog. I thought I had your email, but now I can't find it.

Hope you're doing great,

Betty Manousos said...

i've always been fascinated by gothic novels.
it sure sounds like an interesting read.

big hugs~

Betty Manousos said...

bear hugs!X

Suko said...

Excellent review, as always. This does sound intriguing in a sinister sort of way.

Melissa (Books and Things) said...

As many gothic, zombie, vampire, etc novels I do read, you would think I like horror. Not the case. So, since it does read like a slasher novel/movie, I don't think this one is for me. I'm too much of a chicken. :)

Naida said...

Great review. It does sound like one of those books that is worth the effort.

Stephanie@Fairday's Blog said...

This sounds like an interesting book. I think it is fascinating that you liked it despite being confused. Sounds a bit scary for me.

Michelle Vintagecobweb said...

Thanks Tracy

Good review, I'd read this book.

Slasher novel, not sure why but that made me laugh-I'm probably a weirdo.

Gina R said...

Hmm, I'm feeling the confusion just from this glimpse of it. Not one for my own shelf either, but thanks for the share!