2 Aug 2019

WITCHFINDERS: A SEVENTEENTH ENGLISH TRAGEDY.

WITCHFINDERS: A SEVENTEENTH ENGLISH TRAGEDY by MALCOLM GASKIL.


By the spring of 1645, civil war had exacted a terrible toll upon England. Disease was rife, apocalyptic omens appeared in the skies, and idolators detected in every shire. In a remote corner of Essex, two obscure gentlemen began interrogating women suspected of witchcraft, triggering the most brutal witch-hunt in English history. Witchfinders is a spellbinding study of how Matthew Hopkins, 'the Witchfinder General', and John Stearne extended their campaign across East Anglia, driven by godly zeal. Exploiting the anxiety and lawlessness of the times, and cheered on by ordinary folk, they extracted confessions of satanic pacts resulting in scores of executions.
- Back Cover Blurb

In seventeenth-century England people inhabited a magical universe, a cosmos full of spiritual and occult forces with the power to shape earthly events.
- First Sentence; Preface

To many spectators they must have seemed models of witchery: dirty, ragged and hunched, their faces ravaged by age, hunger and fear. Yet to Arthur Wilson their appearances suggested rather the poor and unfortunate, the decrepit and diseased - mere victims of imagination, hardly the handmaidens of Satan.
- Memorable Moment; Page 125

SOURCE ... Received from a friend, many thanks Katie.

READ FOR A CHALLENGE? ... No.

MY THOUGHTS ... Interesting, insightful, thought provoking, infuriating and perhaps most of all chillingly sobering when, as the author concludes ... 

"how different are we in mentality from our seventeenth century ancestors if 'seventeenth century ancestors' is replaced with 'fellow human beings in Africa and India'?" - pg 286 

A bit dry and meandering, overlong and arguably repetitive; having read the first 15 or so accounts of how the poor individuals deemed witches (rather curiously I thought there was never any assumption that any of them were in fact witches who may well have met in covens, the author seemingly of the opinion that witches did not/do not exist) were watched, interrogated and finally convicted it all became a bit, well, samey. 

As for the execution ... I thought the formatting could have been better; the paragraphs better spaced, the pen and ink illustrations perhaps larger and most of all - why oh why such minute print? - the typeface made bigger, much bigger. 

Other than that ...

Largely following the witch hunt of 1645 - 1647 instigated by the infamous Matthew Hopkins into whom we are given an adequate though what I felt to be a typical insight (interestingly enough there is more actual information given about his father and siblings) and the lesser known John Stearne for whom no history prior to 1645 is given ... most likely because its non-existent  ... until the death of the former and the disappearance into oblivion of the latter.

What I really liked about the book however was the indepth look at how the political climate of the time, the religious issues, the social upheavel all would have contributed to the superstition, the prejudice, the fear, the intolerance that led to the execution of these men, women and, yes, children.


Image result for name felicity

23 comments:

Kelly said...

Having just come off a non-fiction accounting of fourteenth-century England, I'm not sure how much this appeals. I am always fascinated by the topic presented here, but it often frustrates me from my 21st-century perspective. Fear and misunderstanding lead to so much hate. Then and now.

Brian Joseph said...

A fascinating but tragic topic. A couple of years ago I read Witch Hunts in the Western World by Brian Pavlac which was a fairly comprehensive chronicle of witch persecutions in Europe. That was interesting and informative but also a little dry. I also read a few other books on witch persecutions in North America. Humanity can be very stupid and cruel.

Yvonne @ Fiction Books Reviews said...

Hi Felicity,

I can always remember reading Arthur Miller's 'The Crucible', for GCE English 'O' level, back in the 1970's.

That dealt with 17th century witchcraft in Salem USA, although written in the 1950's, it was used to reflect the modern day 'witch-hunts' of Senator Joseph McCarthy, which in some slight way ties into Kelly's perspective of the 21st Century, where nothing much has really changed!

At about one third of the length of 'Witchfinders' though, 'The Crucible' was much more manageable to digest and I can always find a separate book about the British politics of the time, so this one probably isn't for me.

As always, I value your constructive, yet honest reviews :)

Yvonne
xx

Suko said...

Your commentary is clear and honest. It sound like you found book this thought-provoking, overall.

On a different note, I like you new signature, Felicity. Have a lovely weekend.

nightwingsraven said...

Felicity,
I appreciated what you liked about
this book and I am taking your
objections to heart. Perhaps I will
add it to my list.
Eaven

Nas said...

Thanks for sharing your review of it.

Literary Feline said...

How interesting. It's too bad it was a bit dry and repetitive, but it sounds like it was a worthwhile read just the same.

New Release Books said...

Interesting storyline. Thanks for sharing.

Nikki - Notes of Life said...

This sounds like a good read and I need something different for a change.

sarkari results said...

nice blog i love your information awsome work you doing keep it up
Satta king

Play bazaar said...

mere seene se chura raha hai koi
Dur hokar bhi yaad aa raha hai koi,
Ae khuda mujhe usse ek bar milade,
Intezar mere liye kar raha hai koi…play bazaar satta king

Play Bazaar said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
NIKE said...

Satta King and Play Bazaar is a great game that is easy to earn money, so just join and apply,play bazaar satta king

Play Bazaar said...

Practical, Helpful Internet Marketing Suggestions And Tips Play Bazaar Want To Start Internet Marketing? Try Using These Tips! Satta King

prince said...

Make your longer copy easier to read by cutting it down and including a link in the ad to read the rest of it. This gives customers a lot of information in a smaller snippet and then they can decide if they want to read more about it, instead of just having to rummage through a long block of copy. Play Bazaar Want To Start Internet Marketing? Try Using These Tips! Satta King

Play Bazaar said...

Make sure that you have complete contact information listed on your Facebook page. This means that you should have your address, phone number, business hours and any other relevant information. You should make sure to include an email address on the page in case someone wants to contact you off of Facebook. Play Bazaar Expert Advice To Improve Your Facebook Marketing Satta King

PRT said...

How interesting. It's too bad it was a bit dry and repetitive, but it sounds like it was a worthwhile read just the same. Satta king

Unknown said...

FOR LATEST UPDATE
satta result
black satta king
gali result
sattaking

Satta King said...

Really happy to say it’s an interesting post to read.
Satta King

Sattaking said...

Really happy to say it’s an interesting post to read.
Satta King

Play Bazaar said...

Start making money online by taking surveys. A number of websites let you take surveys for small amounts of payment. It's practically impossible to make a living doing this, but it can generate enough money to reinvest into more profitable online money making endeavors. This means you can start making money online with only an investment of your time and not any financial capitol. Satta King Making Money Online Is Much Easier Than You Think Play Bazaar

Delhi Satta said...

Do promotional giveaways on a regular basis. Don't just use this tip for a one-time mailing list builder, but continue to give weekly or monthly prizes. It will generate an interest in your site that peop Satta King Want To Start Internet Marketing? Try Using These Tips! Play Bazaar le will come back to check on again and again, as well as keeping it in their minds on a regular basis.

Astrology said...

Nice Article !!

champion wholesale dealers in Mumbai

champion dealers in Mumbai

champion wholesale dealers in Mumbai

champion jointing sheet in Mumbai


Champion gland packing in Mumbai

fenner wholesale dealers in Mumbai

fenner wholesale products dealers in Mumbai